The official VEX V5 Robotics Competition Question & Answer system has closed for this season.

Official Q&A: VEX V5 Robotics Competition 2024-2025: High Stakes

Usage Guidelines All Questions

2067: SG4 Violation Notes example


Gabriel Garcia
19-Jul-2024

<SG4> Rule SG4 Violation Notes :

Due to the difficulty of determining Match Affecting implications of this rule, most Violations should be considered Minor. However, blatantly intentional and/or Match Affecting Violations (especially during Elimination Matches) may still immediately escalate to a Major Violation at the Head Referee’s discretion. For example, a Top Ring that is removed with 5 seconds remaining by an Alliance who wins the Match by 1 point.

My question is: In this example, does it refer to the top ring being removed from the field, or is it sufficient just to remove it?
Also, is the five seconds mentioned just an example, or does this behavior have the potential to escalate to a major violation at any time during the match?

Answered by committee
30-Jul-2024

All of the Violations Notes that follow rule <SG4> refer to Rings that are removed from the Field.

The example provided in the 4th Violation Note--in which a Top Ring is removed from the Field with 5 seconds remaining in the Match--is simply one example that could reasonably be escalated to a Major Violation by a Head Referee. As with many rulings, Head Referees must make <SG4> decisions based on the full context of the Match and we cannot provide a comprehensive list of scenarios and recommended outcomes.